I have blogged many times, like here, that the best thing one can do for a high probability of economic success is to choose the parents well. But, of course, that is not a choice that is in our control. It is not the parents as in the genes within us, but in terms of where we are born and raised. A good chunk of one's life trajectory is decided right there.
Today, the media reports on yet another research that the geography matters, when it comes to economic success and failures. In this case, it was about "the geography of economic well-being and distress" after the Great Recession:
We found some really startling results. First and foremost, we're looking at the recovery years here. This dataset starts in 2010 - so after the recession is over. And what we find is that not only does the recovery not lift distressed communities, it actually bypasses them altogetherWhat does that look like?
You see double-digit loss in employment. You see significant loss in business establishments - again, double digits. This just does not mirror what's happening in the rest of the country. So those that were most vulnerable before the recession are worse off after those early years of the peak recovery.And if one compares the elite zip codes and the distressed ones?
If you look at the topmost prosperous and the bottommost distressed, it really is like looking at two different countries. In the most-prosperous ZIP codes, you're unlikely to run into somebody who hasn't graduated from high school. You're unlikely to see a vacant home. Your're unlikely to run into somebody who lives below the poverty rate. All of those factors are inverted in the bottom decile, where you have the vast majority of adults out of work. You have establishments eroding very quickly.Ok, what about when we look at the communities in between the two extremes?
Communities between these two extremes have managed only to tread water in recent years, the study found. Employment in communities in the median ZIP codes increased only slightly and the number of businesses did not grow at all.The really, really awful part is this:
once a downward spiral begins, it is very difficult for residents or local political leaders to reverse the slide. “When businesses close and there is no investment, the tax base erodes,” Mr. Lettieri said. “Local governments can’t invest their way out.”Many students in my classes know this all too well from their personal experiences.
So, can you give us a bottom-line?
Where you start has an enormous impact on where you end up in life.Aha! Yet another piece of research about the same conclusion. One can then easily imagine the implications for "equality of opportunity" for kids born in the "wrong" zip codes, right?
I will stay away from discussing this with the students in my economic geography class. I provide them with enough depressing news already!