Showing posts with label pico iyer. Show all posts
Showing posts with label pico iyer. Show all posts

Saturday, December 20, 2014

Trust me, it's a blessing to be a foreigner everywhere!

A few years after moving to Oregon, I authored an op-ed on how I have come to appreciate one part of my identity as India's ambassador.  Unlike early in my American life when I used to tire of people asking me inane and profound questions about India just because I look and speak like one from that country, I later started enjoying that foreigner status--an irony that the wisdom dawned on me after gaining US citizenship.  At least then it dawned, eh!

I know well that I am almost always viewed as an "Indian" at work, at stores, and even in my neighborhood.  A foreigner who is an American.

When visiting India, this "Indian" is again a foreigner--on the streets, in the stores, and even in my parents' eyes.  The other day my father said "you don't know things here.  You are talking like an American." ;)

Of course, when I visit Costa Rica or Ecuador or any country, I am a foreigner.  It is not about how I feel, but about how I am perceived.

Why is this an advantage?  There is no way I will be able to articulate the idea like how Pico Iyer states it:
It’s a blessing to be a foreigner everywhere, detached and able to see the fun in things.
The older me does not worry about it the "foreigner" that I am, and in fact views this special status as a tremendous advantage.  :
As some are born with the blessing of beauty or a musical gift, as some can run very fast without seeming to try, so I was given from birth, I felt, the benefit of being on intimate terms with outsiderdom.
Of course, my travels and experiences are nothing compared to Iyer's, but his essay absolutely speaks to me.  
It’s fashionable in some circles to talk of Otherness as a burden to be borne, and there will always be some who feel threatened by—and correspondingly hostile to—anyone who looks and sounds different from themselves. But in my experience, foreignness can as often be an asset.
My op-ed that I am an ambassador for India, for instance, is the "asset" statement that Iyer makes.  When students ask me whether I am burdened by the otherness, they almost seem ready for me to trash the system and talk about the horrors of being an "other" and are then surprised when they hear me talk positively.  But then, when younger, I would have offered only criticisms ;)
nearly everywhere I knew was foreign, which meant that nearly everywhere had the power to unsettle and surprise me, forever.
Exactly!

Damn these writers who can convey ideas so well; I wish this "iyer" could write like that Iyer! ;)

The foreigner iyer in a "veshti"

Saturday, September 07, 2013

Fight against the Indian way of doing things ... and the only result will be tears

I know exactly when I first realized that I had stopped fighting my battles against India and its Indian-ness. That enlightenment about the change within me came when I was in a cave with the Enlightened One--the Buddha.  Well, sort of.


It was at Ellora, where it was one cave after another of astounding art.  And this was after my previous day at Ajanta.  Paintings and sculptures that were hundreds of years old.  I was so moved by them all.  I was ecstatic to the point of getting emotional.  It was a secular pilgrimage that taught me a lot, especially about the utter insignificance of my singular and momentary existence.

It was mostly a foreign crowd, at Ajanta and at Ellora.  Irrespective of whether we tourists looked Japanese or American or European or, yes, Indian, we walked in and out of the caves with utmost respect and, if talking with others, conversing at low decibels.

Ellora, perhaps because it was less remote than Ajanta, had a few more locals among the tourists. Unlike the mostly foreign tourists at Ajanata who were travelling without kids, Ellora had a few Indian families with kids in tow.  At one of the caves, two middle-aged men, who I imagined as the father and uncle of the kids, not only chose not to teach the kids the proper way to behave at such sites, they even delighted in showing the kids how the sounds echoed in that confined setting.

A young Indian woman, with a camera hanging from one shoulder, a backpack, and a sketchbook in her hand was visibly annoyed.  I smiled at her as I kept walking.

I ran into the same group again at another cave.  The men were boisterous and the kids screamed their lungs out.  The young woman could not bear it anymore and she told them something in Hindi, which seemed like she was expressing her displeasure.  The American I am anymore, I kept going.

Later, at another cave, with mostly unfinished carvings, I saw that young woman in a group with three others.



They seemed like they had come together, perhaps less as tourists as more as scholars.  As I neared them, I told the rest that their friend got pissed off at the noisemakers.  She smiled.

I realized that I had changed.

I was her, and more, when younger.

Even a few years ago, I might have expressed emotions similar to what that young woman felt.  But, not anymore.

There is simply no point fighting with India.  It is as pointless as yelling at a mountain. A tiring thing to do, and nothing ever comes out of it.

Now, when I discuss India, or when I visit India, I simply accept India and her people for the way things are. I do not even attempt to understand the land and its peoples anymore.  They fascinate me, but I have come to realize that trying to understand is frustration, aggravation, anger, disappointment, and many more emotions along those lines.  Simply accepting, on the other hand, means that the land and its peoples are fascinating, beautiful, magical, and more such emotions.

Pico Iyer summarizes all those for me when he writes:
India is not going to change at its core anytime soon, and the challenge for all of us who love it is to see the blessing in that and not the aggravation.
As I often note here and at conversations and in the classroom, India has a momentum of its own and all the external agents who have tried to change its direction not only failed but, ironically, only become Indianized themselves.  As Iyer comments:
Every visitor who goes to India—and I’ve been back twice in the past seven months—knows how the country refuses to conform to plans or international expectations; the only way to survive is to give yourself over to its way of being. Fight against the Indian way of doing things, wish that things were different, and the only result will be tears. Just as you have to turn your watch forwards by half an hour when landing in India, just as you have to check in the batteries from your camera as separate pieces of luggage, just as it can prove impossible to find a working Internet connection in a proud center of high-tech like Hyderabad, so every foreigner has to surrender and realize that things will get done in their own, unexpected ways. The very qualities that make India so culturally alive, textured and itself make it uncommonly reluctant to adjust to the economic rules and geopolitical norms of the world. India most happily changes the lives of those who have no thought of changing India. 
 I wish I could share all these with that young woman.  But, even if I did, for all I know, she will refuse to accept such an interpretation, as much as I refused to give up the good fight when I was once young.  That is the charm of youth anywhere, especially in a beautiful and old India.

At Chennai's Marina Beach

Wednesday, June 05, 2013

I travel because ... Google Earth and iPhone are useless!

"What country are you off to next?" asked a neighbor as we both approached the mailbox station at our street.

I laughed.  For somebody who blogs a lot about various personal stuff, it is strange that I don't seem to always want to give direct answers when I am asked about those very issues in the real world.  It is difficult understanding myself. And I want to understand my fellow humans?  Especially the female kind?  What a Herculean task!

I asked him whether he had been abroad recently because I hadn't seen him for a while.  He and his wife are way past the retirement age and they often travel to different countries.

"We went to Utah" he replied, and we both laughed again for the foreign country that state is, especially when contrasted against this part of Oregon and Southern California from where he and I had moved.

Some day, I will visit that foreign country that is next door.

For now, I need to prepare to meet with my love.

I sometimes wonder how and why a lot more of my fellow humans, particularly those with a lot more money than what I don't have, aren't anywhere as peripatetic as I am.  As much as I intellectually understand that we are individuals with our own likes and dislikes, I can't help wonder why people with more disposable incomes than me don't travel way more than I do.

I would have thought that the photographs and videos that people share on the social media will make them want to travel that much more.  But, does the abundance of those images and sounds end up dulling that desire to go experience new places?  How can that be?  Maybe that is enough for some, as much as my small television set is enough for me?  Different strokes for different folks, yes.

In the age of social media, how does the traveler-extraordinaire, Pico Iyer, adjust to travel writing?
I have to find things that prose can do, that no iPhone can do better. This usually has to do with memory, reflection and the silences between things.
Yes.  That's it.  In my versions of travel and travel-writing, that's exactly what I engage in: "memory, reflection and the silences between things."  Damn, these writers can convey the ideas so well.  No wonder they are the writers and I am but a reader!

Travel is not merely to click a few photographs as some kind of a modern day conquest.  I find travel to be humbling in so many ways.  It is such a humbling experience when I am a nobody in a strange place, especially when I know not the local language.  No special treatment because I have a PhD. Nobody cares. I am like anybody else.  Travel is a phenomenal way to understand and appreciate how insignificant I am in this universe.

As I noted before:
यस्तु संचरते देशान् यस्तु सेवेत पण्डितान् ।
तस्य विस्तारिता बुद्धिः तैलबिंदुरिवांभसि ॥
- सम्योचित पद्यमालिका

He who wanders various countries and serves wise men there 
will expand his knowledge just like oil on water.
- Samayochita Padyamalika

The same idea reflected in the old adage that travel makes a man wiser?

And then when I re-enter the US after a trip abroad, it is truly wonderful to appreciate what G.K. Chesterton wrote:
The object of travel is not to set foot on foreign land; it is at last to set foot on one's own country
 Yes, to set foot on one's own country--hopefully all the wiser.

And that wisdom, I am confident, can never arrive via an iPhone.