Tuesday, January 08, 2019

Traditions, when the times they are a-changin'

Consider the following sentence:
Tradition means living while adhering to usage as befits the refined culture of particular people in a particular time and place.
What an awesome definition of tradition, right?

But, there is way more to that sentence.

What happens to the glorious Tamil literature that followed the rules of the sophisticated grammar that involved the mythical Agastya and the real life Nakkirar?  Do the old canons get thrown out?  Will a new grammar have to be created?  What about the tradition?

It is in this context, writes David Shulman, that Peraciriyar (the great teacher) took on the challenge of "defining, defending, and explicating the classical Tamil past."  Centuries have passed since the Sangam literature, and the times they are a-changin' in the 13th century.  Poets are experimenting, and Peraciriyar thinks and writes about marapu:
Tradition means making poetry while adhering to usage (valakku) as befits the refined culture (nakarikam) of particular people in a particular time and place.
Even as I read that sentence, I was struck by how contemporary the issue is.  Shulman adds:
Let's say that actual speech changes over time [...]; does this mean we need a new grammar in each new period?
That question is relevant even today.

Languages and cultures do not stay stagnant.  If they do, perhaps they will perish.  The Tamil of today is vastly different from the Sangam Tamil, from Nammalvar's Tamil, from Peraciriyar's Tamil ... even from Kannadasan's poetry.  What happens to tradition when the times they are a-changin'?
Tradition means living while adhering to usage as befits the refined culture of particular people in a particular time and place.
A verse from Pukalenti's Nalavenpa and Shulman's commentary appeal to me a lot--even though my traditions are far removed from Peraciriyar's:



I, too, think that everyone should see the world as it is.

No comments: